- FindingSource and sampleStrength
AI voice interview: offers +12%, starts +18%, 30-day retention +17%; 78% chose AI; 5% dropped out
Jabarian & Henkel, 2025 · ~70,000 applicants, entry level, Philippines, randomised
B
Structured interview .42 vs unstructured .19
Sackett and others, 2022 · Meta-analysis
A
Validity rises .20 to .57 with structure
Huffcutt & Arthur, 1994 · Meta-analysis
A
Experience .06 performance, .00 staying; grades .21 / -.02
Van Iddekinge and others, 2019 · Meta-analysis
A
Consistent rule beats judgement by over 50% (.44 vs .28)
Kuncel and others, 2013 · Meta-analysis
A
Testing raised tenure ~25%; overrides cut it 6-7%
Hoffman, Kahn & Li, 2018 · Field data, 15 firms
A
Machine-picked, human-rejected: +14% offers, +0.2-0.4 SD productivity; mostly non-traditional CVs
Cowgill, 2020 · Field study, one large firm
B
Bell curve fits 4.8% of performance samples
Joo, Aguinis & Bradley, 2017 · Hundreds of samples
A
Output spread 48% of mean (complex jobs) vs 19% (simple)
Hunter, Schmidt & Judiesch, 1990 · Meta-analysis
A
Ability barely predicts quitting (.01); unmet expectations do
Griffeth and others, 2000 · Meta-analysis
A
Desire for job, knowing staff, prior tenure predict early leaving
Barrick & Zimmerman · Field studies
A/B
Realistic job previews cut turnover
Earnest and others, 2011 · Meta-analysis
A
Referred hires quit less
Burks and others, 2015 · Firm data, 9 firms
A
Replacement £30,614; 28 weeks to full productivity
Oxford Economics, 2014 · UK employers
A/B
Bad hire up to 3x salary; £42k hire = £132,015
REC, 2017 · UK modelled example
B
41% of employers saw new hires quit within 12 weeks
CIPD, 2024 · UK employer survey
B
3 in 10 measure first-year performance
CIPD, 2026 · 1,014 UK HR professionals
B
960 in 1,000 happy or delighted at the end of the call; 11 in 1,000 not
Kit, end-of-call rating · Kit calls
Measured
Per 1,000 calls: 783 completed; 276 between 7pm and 7am; 361 outside working hours (Mon to Fri, 8am to 6pm), weekends included. Median call 22.9 min
Kit, PostHog · 14 Jul to 25 Oct 2026
Measured
Dot Collective: 556 applications, 293 people spoken to, 64.5 hours
Kit platform · 7 jobs
Measured
Strength reflects sample, method and how close the setting is to UK professional hiring.